Should I Stay Or Should I Go?

By

If you have grown dissatisfied with the church you attend, you are probably wrestling with what to do about it. You are not the first believer to face this question, and there is no single right answer for every situation.

The choice usually narrows to five options:

  1. Stay and keep quiet
  2. Stay and try to effect change
  3. Stay and stop supporting financially
  4. Leave and find a new church
  5. Leave and stop attending organized church altogether

Each has real pros and real cons. None of them is automatically right or wrong. Walk through them honestly and see which one matches your situation, your conscience, and your season of life.

1. Stay and keep quiet

You remain at the church. You do not raise the issues that bother you. You attend, you fellowship, you give as you have been, and you keep your concerns private.

Pros

  • Preserves existing relationships with friends, family, and community.
  • Keeps your Sunday rhythm and routine intact.
  • Avoids conflict with leadership or other members.
  • Allows time to discern whether your concerns are real, growing, or temporary.
  • If you have children, they keep their friendships and activities.

Cons

  • Internal tension grows when you sit through teaching or practices you disagree with.
  • Money you give continues funding things you may not endorse.
  • Silence can feel like agreement — to others, and eventually to your own conscience.
  • Long-term, the unspoken conflict can sour your view of church entirely.
  • You miss the chance to be an honest voice that others may quietly need to hear.

2. Stay and try to effect change

You remain, but you speak up. You raise questions with leadership privately, suggest reforms, ask for transparency where it is missing, and lovingly push for the church to align more closely with scripture.

Pros

  • Honors the biblical pattern of going to a brother directly (Matthew 18:15).
  • May produce real positive change for the whole congregation.
  • Demonstrates love and commitment to the body, not just personal preference.
  • Keeps you engaged rather than embittered.
  • Other members who quietly feel the same may find courage in your honest voice.

Cons

  • Most established churches resist change, especially around money and authority.
  • You may be labeled divisive, rebellious, or unsubmissive.
  • Leadership may shut you down or, in some cases, formally discipline you.
  • The emotional cost of repeated conversations that go nowhere is real.
  • You may end up leaving anyway — only later, and more wounded.

3. Stay and stop supporting financially

You continue to attend but redirect your tithe and offerings elsewhere — to direct aid for the poor, missionaries you know personally, Bible translation, persecuted believers, or other giving that matches your conscience.

Pros

  • Aligns your money with your convictions without leaving the community.
  • Frees you from funding things you cannot endorse in good conscience.
  • Sends giving to people and causes with less institutional overhead.
  • The New Testament pattern of giving is largely person-to-person and need-based, not institutional (Acts 2:45, 2 Corinthians 8–9).
  • Allows you to keep relationships intact while quietly making a stand.

Cons

  • Some churches treat decreased giving as a discipline issue or a red flag.
  • Leadership may notice and pressure you.
  • You may feel like you are using the building and community without contributing.
  • Without an honest conversation, your silent protest can feel passive-aggressive.
  • Friction may grow even if no one says anything directly.

4. Leave and find a new church

You conclude the current church is not the right place for you, but you still want a local congregation. You look for one whose teaching, leadership, and practices align more closely with what you find in scripture.

Pros

  • Honors your conscience without abandoning the principle of gathering with believers.
  • A healthier church can be a real blessing — good teaching, genuine community, faithful leadership.
  • Removes the daily tension of attending somewhere you cannot endorse.
  • Models for your children that following truth matters more than convenience.
  • Shows that you are not anti-church — just opposed to this particular arrangement.

Cons

  • Finding a healthy church is genuinely hard, especially in some regions.
  • You may try several before one fits — or you may not find one at all.
  • Leaving costs friendships and disrupts family routines.
  • Children may resist the change.
  • Sometimes the new church turns out to have its own problems, and the cycle starts over.

5. Leave and stop attending organized church

You step away from institutional church entirely. You continue in personal study, prayer, and worship. You may meet informally with other believers, but you no longer attend a traditional Sunday service.

Pros

  • Removes you from arrangements you believe are not biblical.
  • Frees your time and money for direct ministry, family, and your personal walk with God.
  • Many believers in this position report deeper personal study and prayer.
  • The New Testament shows believers meeting in homes (Romans 16:5, 1 Corinthians 16:19), not just institutional buildings.
  • You stop subsidizing patterns you cannot endorse.

Cons

  • Loss of weekly Christian fellowship is real and often underestimated.
  • Hebrews 10:25 (“not forsaking the assembling of ourselves together”) deserves honest weight, even if your reading is that it does not require a traditional service. See Forsaking the Assembly? for a fuller treatment.
  • It is easy to drift into isolation, which is spiritually unhealthy.
  • Children miss the structured exposure to other believers.
  • Some who leave in anger or hurt drift further than they expected — from God Himself, not just from a building. Without intentional effort, scripture and prayer can quietly fade.

A few thoughts before you decide

“If any of you lack wisdom, let him ask of God, that giveth to all men liberally, and upbraideth not; and it shall be given him.” (James 1:5)

  • Pray honestly. Ask God to show you what He wants, not what is easiest.
  • Talk to your spouse if you are married. This decision affects both of you, and your children.
  • Do not act in the heat of frustration. Give yourself a few weeks of clear-headed thought before any major step.
  • Examine your motives. Is the concern truth, or is it hurt feelings? Both are real, but they call for different responses.
  • Whatever you decide should reflect your conscience and your reading of scripture — not fatigue, social pressure, or anger.

You are not alone in wrestling with this. Many sincere believers have stood in front of these same five doors and chosen different ones for different seasons of life. The goal is not to land where someone else landed. The goal is to land where God leads you.

Similar Posts